The Cato Institute Just Ranked Gavin Newsom as the Third Worst Governor in America

Gavin Newsom just signed the largest tax hike in California state history.

Now a major think tank has the receipts on what that kind of governing actually costs.

The Cato Institute just ranked Newsom the third worst governor in America – and one number buried in the report explains exactly why he should never get near the White House.

The Report That Should End His Presidential Ambitions

The Cato Institute's 2026 Freedom in the 50 States report did something no liberal California media outlet will touch: it graded every governor in America on whether their policies made residents more free or less free.

Newsom scored 48th out of 50.

California itself ranked 44th overall – pulling an F grade with a 1.95 out of 10 overall freedom score – and 48th specifically in economic freedom.

The governors who finished worse than Newsom were New York's Kathy Hochul and Hawaii's Josh Green.

That's the company Newsom keeps.

The Cato analyst who authored the study, Stephen Slivinski, made the methodology clear: governors who push policies that make their states less free score lower than the state itself.

Newsom didn't just inherit a bad situation.

He made it worse on purpose.

What Newsom's Freedom Score Actually Measures

The Cato report doesn't grade governors on vibes.

It measures government spending and taxes, business regulations, restrictions on building, school choice, Second Amendment protections, medical freedom, and First Amendment adherence.

Newsom fails on almost every category.

He signed what a California Taxpayers Association spokesperson called "the largest tax hike in state history from a dollar standpoint" – new levies on healthcare providers and cloud-based software tucked inside a $351.7 billion budget that will drain $900 million more annually from California families and businesses starting in 2027.

The state's minimum wage hits $17.40 next year.

California still has no right-to-work law.

Licensing requirements to start a business remain among the most burdensome in the country.

Zoning and environmental regulations have strangled housing construction for years, helping drive median home prices into territory most working Californians will never reach.

The Voters Are Already Voting With Their Feet

The data that Newsom refuses to acknowledge is sitting in U.S. Census Bureau reports.

From 2020 through 2025, 1.6 million more people fled California than moved in – the largest domestic population exodus of any state in America.

Los Angeles County alone shed 64,000 residents in 2025.

A poll found that 56% of Californians have considered leaving the state, with cost of living as the primary driver.

The top 1% of earners pay roughly 40% of California's income taxes.

When they leave – and they are leaving – the math doesn't work.

Newsom's response to the exodus has been to deny it's happening, then pivot to talking about how much he loves California.

Meanwhile, the freest states in the Cato rankings – Arizona, Montana, Nevada, Florida, and Idaho – are the states California residents keep moving to.

The Governor Who Wants to Run America

Here's what fires me up about this story.

Newsom has spent years positioning himself as the alternative to Trump – flying to Florida to lecture DeSantis, buying national ad time in red states, calculating every move around a presidential run.

The Cato ranking just documented exactly what Newsom's vision for America looks like in practice.

It looks like 48th place.

It looks like an F grade.

It looks like 1.6 million people packing up and leaving.

The freest governor in America right now is Montana's Greg Gianforte, who earned an A.

Second place went to Colorado's Jared Polis – a Democrat – which is the part Newsom's team can't explain away.

What Newsom built in California – the tax structure, the regulations, the zoning laws, the $352 billion spending machine – is exactly what a Newsom administration would try to build for the country.

Voters just watched him run that experiment for seven years.

The results are in.


Sources:

  • Annie Gaus, "Brutal study ranks the worst governors in America – and it's terrible news for Gavin Newsom," California Post, October 26, 2026.
  • Stephen Slivinski, "Freedom in the 50 States 2026," Cato Institute, October 2026.
  • "Only the Homeless Population Is Growing in Newsom's California," Issues & Insights, August 19, 2026.
  • Titus Wu, "California's 'largest-ever tax hike' eviscerated by critics," New York Post, July 9, 2026.
  • "Californians to Pay Billions of Dollars More in Taxes," San Joaquin Valley Sun, 2026.